I would prefer a more photorealistic look. Also, I would standardize your font size and compensate for differences in label lengths with varying kerning.

Here's what I whipped up quick:



If you're a true fan you could go to the stadium and get a better shot of the scoreboard than I was able to source online. Also, I would do the same with the transport controls - I wasn't able to source a decent aerial view of the Fenway diamond, however. Do you have an airplane and a decent camera? It would take a little work to input the scoreboard data for the game/inning you wanted and make it still look authentic, but it's definitely do-able.

P.S. The "SOX" button could be a macro that automatically switches to the correct inputs and channel of the most likely place a current Sox game would be broadcast.