On January 18, 2011 at 05:42, tb123 said...
Hi Matt, that doesnt actually seem to be true and would love to hear how you believe it is supposed to work.
The new ATV2 supports AirPlay w/ music and video. Maybe photo, I don't have one for testing. Not sure what else to explain on my comment.
I have just purchased a Denon 4311 and want to purchase the Airplay option as it looks great, however, I have been following the 4311 threads on AVS for some time.
A few Denon and Marantz owners have recently taken up the Airplay option only to find it is "locked" or "hijacks" the Main Zone of the AVR. You can also turn On or Off Zone 2/ Zone 3, but you HAVE to have the Main Zone on for the others to work. In a HT situation this is useless.
While I am aware of this from using the feature, I'm not certain as to where the implementation guidelines came from, Apple or Denon. I am not certain as to how the feature will grow within the existing products and or future products to come.
In most cases, myself included, Airplay will be for playing music in external Zones (like you can with the standard Net/ USB interface) and extremely unlikely to ever be played in the main zone in my HT. It seems the Denon only presents 1 "speaker" for Airplay to use, which defaults and is tied to the main zone.
Please note though, when adding an ATV or Airport Express these products also only present themselves as 1 "speaker".
If you look at it from another products usage, you would need multiple ATV2/Airports to achieve the same outcome with discrete control.
Maybe that's the solution, Denon+AirPlay for "Main" then ATV2 "Multi"(with a Digital to Analog converter on it). Now you'll have two feeds/control! Some will say that my suggestion is not realistic. Pause and consider how many CI's have installed multiple SAT/CBL boxes just for discrete Multi Zone music/control at a much higher cost + monthly subscription.
AVS are running an FAQ thread with a few comments in it seperate to the normal 4311 thread.
Link to FAQUntil Denon confirms or denys this is the permanent functionality, a lot of folks are buying an ATV and using this as the Airplay interface. The current implementation of Airplay appears to be extremely limited. Do you know if this is likely to change at all?
Sorry, I don't have any other info at this time on how the feature will evolve.
thanks for reading
cheers
TB
Last edited by M Hi Fi on January 18, 2011 15:57.