On August 17, 2008 at 18:17, 39 Cent Stamp said...
Are you telling me that my idea of what hard buttons are
bad? If so please tell me what your idea of good hard
buttons would be.
Did you read the whole thread or are you assuming my stick
figure sketch is an attempt at visual and ergonomic design?
The stick figure sketch i spent all of 20 minutes on was
meant to be a visual aid while talking about the hard
buttons i would like to see on a hand held remote.
On a side note.. while i agree my sketch is ugly and cheap
looking.. AMX doesnt seem to think so. Looks pretty close
to what they have IMO:)

yes i'm saying that in my VERY humble and borderline worthless opinion your button layout is awful, and i personally HATE touchscreens so soft buttons are a must. the pic of those other remotes are all terrible looking, again, IMO of course.
in fact i think the 880 has ALMOST the perfect button layout. the only things i would change would be to switch PREV CHAN and MUTE (and i personally would prefer if PREV CHAN was a LIST button), switch PAUSE and STOP, switch INFO and EXIT (keeping in mind i'm a lefty), place the skip buttons right above the transport buttons much like the 900 (better to use them as page up/down in menus), and possibly replace LISTEN/WATCH with ACTIVITY/DEVICE.
while we're discussing the perfect remote, what really drew me to buy an H1 (i of course returned it due to the annoying TS and lack of programability) were the shape and layout of the transport buttons. the way Play and Pause are designed is just perfect imo.
and yes i did realize that was a quick sketch and was only to represent button layout and not size/shape etc.