I think this post points out the real Elephant in the Room, and that is that even though the Pronto Pro is much better built, and has a tremendous amount of flexability and versatility and every other form of geeky goodnes, the prontos lack Ergonomics and Simplicity. First of all I personally would never buy any remote that requires two hands to operate or has soft buttons, because that just eliminates my comfort zone which is a remote in one hand and a Drink in the other :) and I need to know all the buttons by feel so I don't have to look down every 10 seconds. Secondly I don't want to Enrole in "Remote University" in order to program my remote.
Almost all the Harmony remotes are user friendly and well designed so that they are a easy to program for the Novice and a joy to use. Yet for the more geeky user they can still do many of the more complex commands you just need to dig deeper and spend the time and make the proper macro's etc. Yes it will not do everything a Pronto will but then again 99% of people will never need all of that and the Harmony Ergonomics make the daily use so much more enjoyable and to me that is the main thing that counts.
On December 17, 2008 at 10:52, raylinds said...
I hope I can help as I just made the switch from a Pronto
Pro 9600 to the Harmony One. A lot of people will probably
think I am crazy, but I really prefer hard buttons to
soft. I was a little hesitant at first because I had
some situations that I thought the H1 might not be able
to handle:
I have remote comtrolled audio and video switchers that,
according to the Harmony website, are not supported.
Not suprising as they are obscure brands.
I have X10 controlled lights.
I have three Sony DVD jukeboxes and you have to assign
each remote to the specific unit, so you can control each
unit seperately.
I went ahead and took the chance since it is a learning
remote, and I was very pleasantly suprised that the H1
was up and running quickly and perfectly. When I entered
the make and model of my switchers, it turned out that
they were supported! I also got the three DVD jukeboxes
installed perfectly. I was able to set up activities
to do everything that my Pronto did with macros.
I love the ergonomics and buttons of the H1 and find that
th IR seems to work a little better for me than the Pronto
(sometimes with the pronto a function in a macro seems
to not get received).
The only advantage that I can see, with my remote usage,
is you can get fancier and much more customizable graphics
with the Pronto. This was not an issue for me, but may
be for some users.
I will be selling my Pronto on EBay for a lot more than
I payed for the H1. I couldn't be happier and am not
looking back. You mileage, of course, may vary.
please feel free to ask me any questions you may have
if you want more details. You can email me if you wish.
Disclaimer: I have no affiliation whatsoever with Logitech.
:)
regards,
Ray