Over a period of a few years, I think I've heard about roughly a dozen examples of TV models in which sending unknown IR commands has done serious damage.
Sometime the description of what happened is so implausible that I suspect the user did something else wrong or misinterpreted an unrelated failure. Sometimes the description is plausible and supported by independent reports from other people with related models. Sometimes I can only guess.
Frequently I advise someone to look for themselves to make an informed decision about whether testing for discrete codes is safe. That's a little unfair, because I don't know a decent way to search for those threads; Why should someone with less experience searching remote control forums manage that better than I could.
I think this forum needs a page of direct links to some of the first hand accounts of these disasters.
I don't have such a list. But as one instance was just posted, I might as well attempt to start such a list and edit other links in later as I happen on them.
Panasonic Plasma 42PV500:
[Link: remotecentral.com]ADVENT TV Q2035A
[Link: hifi-remote.com]ADVENT TV 2735
[Link: remotecentral.com]Sharp LC-52D92U (serious but nonpermanent problem IIUC)
[Link: remotecentral.com]I'd prefer not to discuss (especially not to argue) the questions and conclusions about the dangers of such testing in THIS thread. That would make it harder to see the links to first hand accounts, which are my intended pupose here.
If anyone else has links to first hand accounts of serious damage from sending IR signals, please add them to this thread.
I know I've seen several first hand accounts of Toshiba TV's destroyed, but at the moment I can't find any.
For the record, testing all 256 commands did no harm whatever to MY Toshiba TV nor to any other device I personally have tested.
The subject line of this thread was meant to grab attention more than to be exclusively descriptive of the thread. I do mean to include devices other than TV and serious damage at levels less than "destroyed" and cases (such as most of the Advent TV examples) where discrete code testing WOULD HAVE caused the disaster but actually some other activity sending the bad command did it.
Last edited by johnsfine
on February 20, 2007 09:50.