On June 18, 2006 at 09:40, jeff2180 said...
Those are all correct Statements.
Here is how adiago is different.
Crestron AES: 10 sources/6 zones upto 40 sources/24
zones
This is incorrect. Adding expansion units does adds to the number of zones controlled not the number of source inputs. You might wish to get cute and take an output from each AES into the input of the other but I'd argue that you'd be better off selling a Bipad8 then using the Adagio this way. Stock, without games or tricks, expansion units add outputs not inputs to the system.
Niles ICS: 6 sources/6 zones upto 30 sources/30
zones
I am still a dealer but I don't do much business with Niles, partly due to their new relationship with AVID and partly do their local rep placing them into distribution ( eg., ADI as well as his own local retail, eh, wholesale store ( until the AVID deal went though ). That and the IPOWER and some of the issues with the RVL replacement ( I forget the number but it was line level out to a 12 channel amp ) left a bad taste so I have not looked closely at the ICS. I'd wager that it, too, will not do 30 individual sources, but I'll let Mr. Stearns comment.
Niles does not have an audio server. It is working
on a module for Escient but it will just be metadata
no jacket art.
I am no Escient fan. But I will argue about the efficacy of clip out on a CD server. Clip art is nice but information is better. I'd rather Niles did not choose sides and had modules for both Escient and Request but the point I'd make is that, until recently, it was rather difficult, and required an Elan like solution to get clip art onto a Crestron panel. Niles, and in particular, Mr. Stearns is very smart. If all they are missing is clip art they are not missing much. Data of graphics is not missing much. I want to find my music and if I lose a bit of cool graphics that add little but "coolness" it is a trade off that doesn't lose much.
Both are excellent new products but it up to the
system designer to figure out what the clients
needs are now and in the future.
Hope this helps
Jeff
I am available for consultation for the right price. Currently 3 manufacturers have been smart enough to use my free services to the benefit of all. Mr. Stearn's participation can only be seen as a positive.
Alan