Your Universal Remote Control Center
RemoteCentral.com
Custom Installers' Lounge Forum - View Post
Previous section Next section Previous page Next page Up level
Up level
The following page was printed from RemoteCentral.com:

Login:
Pass:
 
 

Page 2 of 3
Topic:
30 Zones of music, budget minded customer
This thread has 38 replies. Displaying posts 16 through 30.
Post 16 made on Friday April 26, 2019 at 13:22
ichbinbose
Select Member
Joined:
Posts:
August 2011
1,824
On April 26, 2019 at 12:03, Impaqt said...
30 zones and "budget conscious" doesnt really go hand and hand. trying to design/build a cheap system for that never end well.. but hey, everyone needs to learn I guess.

^^^
This
Post 17 made on Friday April 26, 2019 at 13:46
Brad Humphrey
Super Member
Joined:
Posts:
February 2004
2,598
I think the question that has to be learned 1st is: How did the electrician wire it?
Because if it is anything like the electrician's around here, there will be only 1 option = 70V amp.
Because the idiots would have wired from speaker to speaker, in series, for 60 speakers.
Post 18 made on Friday April 26, 2019 at 15:18
ichbinbose
Select Member
Joined:
Posts:
August 2011
1,824
On April 26, 2019 at 13:46, Brad Humphrey said...
I think the question that has to be learned 1st is: How did the electrician wire it?
Because if it is anything like the electrician's around here, there will be only 1 option = 70V amp.
Because the idiots would have wired from speaker to speaker, in series, for 60 speakers.

That would suck so much, but yeah I’ve seen dumb wiring like this by Electrican’s
Post 19 made on Friday April 26, 2019 at 15:20
Archibald "Harry" Tuttle
Advanced Member
Joined:
Posts:
May 2009
974
"30 Zones of music, budget minded customer"???? Another one of those guys? Somehow 30 zones of music and budget minded don't really go together. lol

Definitely avoid the Sonos nightmare that project would certainly be.

Do it right, sell him an 8 stack of these...

[Link: usa.yamaha.com]
I came into this game for the action, the excitement. Go anywhere, travel light, get in, get out, wherever there's AV trouble, a man alone.
OP | Post 20 made on Friday April 26, 2019 at 17:46
sirroundsound
Senior Member
Joined:
Posts:
November 2003
1,097
Thanks, sorry for the delay in responding.
As I did not have anything to do with the design, speaker placement etc, I can only work with what I have been given.
Initially, without documents, I was told that there were around 20 zones of music.
It is a very large home, but as many have pointed out, it does not need to be able to play 20 different things in 20 different rooms. This is more about being able to select from maybe 6 or 8 sources (His, Hers, kids, Guest, Patio... whatever. I will have to figure out naming with the client) and turn on, control volume in 20 - now 30 areas of the house. As we have no option of grouping areas and just adding volume controls, we are dealing with 30 "zones" There are at least 41 or 42 pairs of speakers throughout.
Initially, my thought was to use 20 Sonos Amps and call it a day. Not for the purpose of having something different playing everywhere, but for just the ease of set up and use.
When the client walked through with us and we discovered we were up to 30 zones, and an extra $10K was not really in the budget, I figured there would be another way to do this. I also saw a few comments about using Sonos closer to it's limits can start to have problems.

I like the idea of Yamaha as there is an RTI driver, and there are two Surround systems that I could use Yamaha AVR's in and have music cast in those areas too.
Problem,I was first told was Yamaha does not work well past 10 zones, although the Yamaha pieces mentioned above do say up to 32 zones.

I have done Clare Controls once a number of years ago with previous employer, not sure if I am comfortable with their product, really do not hear much about it.


So looking at matrix Audio switching / amplification and something I can reliably control through RTI became the search.
Matrix audio, there are lots of choices, I have used many over the years.

RTI AD8x, can use 4 of them, and add more amplification for the couple of areas that would need it. Then it just becomes the music streaming device that is the real question.

Lots of people poo poo on Fusion, I used it in the past, had a couple of systems that worked fine and a couple that became service calls regularly. They are claiming to be using new software, and have in house RTI driver. Plus if I have read correctly, can use Spotify from the RTI app, not have to go to your phone to play.
I have only ever used Autonomics in Savant systems, so no idea if it works well in RTI land, and clients did not have Spotify in those systems.

Bluesound is also very nice but no Sirius radio, which I think with so many people having it in their cars, they would want it in their homes too.

Any RTI guru's out there that can tell me which streaming music box works great in RTI land?
Post 21 made on Friday April 26, 2019 at 18:37
Richie Rich
Senior Member
Joined:
Posts:
July 2002
1,150
On April 25, 2019 at 21:21, punter16 said...
Our last job with 20+ Sonos pieces was a nightmare. I would never do it again. This was a couple years back but we had issue after issue (music dropping over and over and over and over) and this was with a $50,000 network in place.

Limited Connects w/amplification...that I could do happily.

I have done a few bigger Sonos systems but he one that was about 18 zones had similar issues with a similar level of network.

Putting the Sonos on its own vlan made it work pretty reliably.

But honestly most of the larger house audio jobs I have done have been Crestron/Sonnex. XM tuner, dedicated sat/cable box, Sonos Connect or 3.
Doing it this way also allows the house video sources to be available in each room's in wall/in ceiling speakers.
I am a trained professional..... Do not attempt this stunt at home.
Post 22 made on Friday April 26, 2019 at 19:15
buzz
Super Member
Joined:
Posts:
May 2003
4,376
Find out who set the budget and their criteria. Be careful. Don't meet the budget while failing to meet expectations. I think that you'll need to "manage" this potential customer.
Post 23 made on Friday April 26, 2019 at 20:33
roddymcg
Loyal Member
Joined:
Posts:
September 2003
6,796
I would avoid integrating Sonos with any control system if at all possible. Their last update broke integration with Savant and most likely others. Sonos on its own for audio is fine.

What streaming services do they use? Autonomics with your flavor of amps would be a solid solution using as many streamers as they need. We lean towards single zone streamers so they can have as many unique accounts as they need, 5 different Spotify accounts for example.

As for budget its hard to sympathize with someone that has 30 zones of audio they are out of money. Don't let the budget dictate you into a less than optimal system as you will pay for this for years to come. Give him 20 zones of audio and add the last 10 when they come up with more cash. ;)
When good enough is not good enough.
Post 24 made on Friday April 26, 2019 at 20:41
Jeff at Zektor
Active Member
Joined:
Posts:
August 2009
596
On April 26, 2019 at 17:46, sirroundsound said...
Thanks, sorry for the delay in responding.
As I did not have anything to do with the design, speaker placement etc, I can only work with what I have been given.
Initially, without documents, I was told that there were around 20 zones of music.
It is a very large home, but as many have pointed out, it does not need to be able to play 20 different things in 20 different rooms. This is more about being able to select from maybe 6 or 8 sources (His, Hers, kids, Guest, Patio... whatever. I will have to figure out naming with the client) and turn on, control volume in 20 - now 30 areas of the house. As we have no option of grouping areas and just adding volume controls, we are dealing with 30 "zones" There are at least 41 or 42 pairs of speakers throughout.
Initially, my thought was to use 20 Sonos Amps and call it a day. Not for the purpose of having something different playing everywhere, but for just the ease of set up and use.
When the client walked through with us and we discovered we were up to 30 zones, and an extra $10K was not really in the budget, I figured there would be another way to do this. I also saw a few comments about using Sonos closer to it's limits can start to have problems.

I like the idea of Yamaha as there is an RTI driver, and there are two Surround systems that I could use Yamaha AVR's in and have music cast in those areas too.
Problem,I was first told was Yamaha does not work well past 10 zones, although the Yamaha pieces mentioned above do say up to 32 zones.

I have done Clare Controls once a number of years ago with previous employer, not sure if I am comfortable with their product, really do not hear much about it.


So looking at matrix Audio switching / amplification and something I can reliably control through RTI became the search.
Matrix audio, there are lots of choices, I have used many over the years.

RTI AD8x, can use 4 of them, and add more amplification for the couple of areas that would need it. Then it just becomes the music streaming device that is the real question.

Lots of people poo poo on Fusion, I used it in the past, had a couple of systems that worked fine and a couple that became service calls regularly. They are claiming to be using new software, and have in house RTI driver. Plus if I have read correctly, can use Spotify from the RTI app, not have to go to your phone to play.
I have only ever used Autonomics in Savant systems, so no idea if it works well in RTI land, and clients did not have Spotify in those systems.

Bluesound is also very nice but no Sirius radio, which I think with so many people having it in their cars, they would want it in their homes too.

Any RTI guru's out there that can tell me which streaming music box works great in RTI land?

RTI does have a great driver for all of our ProAudio models. A ProAudio 16X32 would give you 40 inputs and 32 outputs with 12 additional 12V triggers which should meet your budget. Good luck on the project.
Jeff Haynes
The CA Guy
Coastal Source [email protected] 619-889-3700
Post 25 made on Friday April 26, 2019 at 22:35
IRkiller
Advanced Member
Joined:
Posts:
May 2012
920
On April 26, 2019 at 17:46, sirroundsound said...

Any RTI guru's out there that can tell me which streaming music box works great in RTI land?

It's slim pickins on the available services, but the Nuvo streamer is near flawless with RTI. A dozen or so out in the field with little to no trouble after updates including my own home.

In fact, I'd take a hard look at a Zektor Proaudio w/ competent amps, XP6 and a Nuvo streamer. You won't find better reliability + flexibility.
how in the hell does ernie make money?
Post 26 made on Saturday April 27, 2019 at 02:37
dunnersfella
Long Time Member
Joined:
Posts:
October 2016
309
Re: MusicCast zones, the new products can handle the number you're looking at. Older products, not so much.

The quad streaming amps are darned cool and are designed to pretty much do what you're looking to do... factor in RTI, some sources like turntables, CD players, theatre receivers and you should be sweet.
This industry is not getting cheaper and cheaper, we're simply convincing ourselves that we have to push the cheapest option to customers.
#makesonosgreatagain
Post 27 made on Saturday April 27, 2019 at 10:49
Cams
Long Time Member
Joined:
Posts:
January 2006
485
this can be done with RTI and Sonos Connects. We have done houses with 19 zones, with the same setup.
(4) AD8x and 8 Sonos Connects. To save on there "budget" you can drop down to 3 AD8 and less sonos connects and always add more later. If they need more connects then its a different ball game with the "budget". CLient needs to understand that.

For the outdoor zones just add a crown or some other powerful amp to get more power.

The most important question is how are you with RTI programming? If you are new or don't have experience programming these big systems you can have issues and client will think the system sucks if its not working right.

Regarding what streamer works best with RTI. They are a ton out there but some missing other things then other, like searching inside RTI, etc
We stick with sonos and make the client select there Favs from ANY service and it shows on our RTI interface. Very Simple and clients love it.
Yea they (sonos) broke integration with RTI but RTI released a fix under 24hours. That was only time integration was broke where it effected RTI.

If you need help programming or want to sub out the programming DM me.
OP | Post 28 made on Sunday April 28, 2019 at 09:52
sirroundsound
Senior Member
Joined:
Posts:
November 2003
1,097
Have been doing RTI for a long time (T1 and T2c remotes were popular back then), so no worry's about that.
Still have reservations about Sonos and RTI (or any control system)
As mentioned, Audio switching is easy, lots of options, I actually have an AD8x sitting around somewhere, so three more of those and adding a couple of bigger amps for areas where needed takes care of that part.
I recall previous company did a Nuvo system for a client and did have a couple of little quirks.
So I think at this point I will look at Autonomics or Fusion. Have to compare as I see they both have new streamers since the last time I dealt with either.
Post 29 made on Sunday April 28, 2019 at 10:57
highfigh
Loyal Member
Joined:
Posts:
September 2004
8,322
On April 26, 2019 at 17:46, sirroundsound said...
Thanks, sorry for the delay in responding.
As I did not have anything to do with the design, speaker placement etc, I can only work with what I have been given.
Initially, without documents, I was told that there were around 20 zones of music.
It is a very large home, but as many have pointed out, it does not need to be able to play 20 different things in 20 different rooms. This is more about being able to select from maybe 6 or 8 sources (His, Hers, kids, Guest, Patio... whatever. I will have to figure out naming with the client) and turn on, control volume in 20 - now 30 areas of the house. As we have no option of grouping areas and just adding volume controls, we are dealing with 30 "zones" There are at least 41 or 42 pairs of speakers throughout.
Initially, my thought was to use 20 Sonos Amps and call it a day. Not for the purpose of having something different playing everywhere, but for just the ease of set up and use.
When the client walked through with us and we discovered we were up to 30 zones, and an extra $10K was not really in the budget, I figured there would be another way to do this. I also saw a few comments about using Sonos closer to it's limits can start to have problems.

I like the idea of Yamaha as there is an RTI driver, and there are two Surround systems that I could use Yamaha AVR's in and have music cast in those areas too.
Problem,I was first told was Yamaha does not work well past 10 zones, although the Yamaha pieces mentioned above do say up to 32 zones.

I think any issues with Yamaha would involve network setup more than anything else but I could be wrong, since I haven't used that many in one system.

I wouldn't make any decisions or recommendations until I got everything in writing. Sounds like too many people are involved for this to be an easy "I would do this" and get an "OK, go ahead". I think I would sit with the homeowner and explain that you need more detail in the requirements list. Find out how many sources they really need and that will tell you a lot. You may only need a four input matrix, or you may be able to use one amplifier for more than one zone.

This would be a good time to recommend that amplifier manufacturers add IR/IP control to their products. Wouldn't be a terrible thing if separate volume controls had it, but their time isn't long, IMO.
My mechanic told me, "I couldn't repair your brakes, so I made your horn louder."
Post 30 made on Monday April 29, 2019 at 14:35
JoeFlabitz
Select Member
Joined:
Posts:
December 2008
1,517
Watch your Sonos update...

[Link: en.community.sonos.com]
Page 2 of 3


Jump to


Protected Feature Before you can reply to a message...
You must first register for a Remote Central user account - it's fast and free! Or, if you already have an account, please login now.

Please read the following: Unsolicited commercial advertisements are absolutely not permitted on this forum. Other private buy & sell messages should be posted to our Marketplace. For information on how to advertise your service or product click here. Remote Central reserves the right to remove or modify any post that is deemed inappropriate.

Hosting Services by ipHouse