Your Universal Remote Control Center
RemoteCentral.com
Custom Installers' Lounge Forum - View Post
Previous section Next section Previous page Next page Up level
Up level
The following page was printed from RemoteCentral.com:

Login:
Pass:
 
 

Page 2 of 2
Topic:
What has changed with Harmony recently shutting down services ?
This thread has 26 replies. Displaying posts 16 through 27.
Post 16 made on Wednesday January 9, 2019 at 09:41
highfigh
Loyal Member
Joined:
Posts:
September 2004
8,311
On January 9, 2019 at 08:55, andrewinboulder said...
In general I agree that Harmony has done some pretty slick stuff with their newer remotes. Now if only it wasn't sold all over on the internet.

As in all cases, there's always someone out there who will sell for less than UAP and other pricing guidelines. They're working on it and this is the reason the Elite Pro is only available through distribution. For those who say that the added year warranty and extra emitters don't matter, it's up to them to sell it- they shouldn't rely on anything to sell itself.

It's called 'over-coming the objection'.
My mechanic told me, "I couldn't repair your brakes, so I made your horn louder."
Post 17 made on Wednesday January 9, 2019 at 09:48
techvalley
Long Time Member
Joined:
Posts:
July 2012
197
-
"try to become not a man of success, but try rather to become a man of value."
Post 18 made on Wednesday January 9, 2019 at 09:53
techvalley
Long Time Member
Joined:
Posts:
July 2012
197
My post keeps showing wrong, attempting to reply to Goldenrule- apologies, I hit reply instead of quote. Whats reply button for?
"try to become not a man of success, but try rather to become a man of value."
Post 19 made on Wednesday January 9, 2019 at 09:57
techvalley
Long Time Member
Joined:
Posts:
July 2012
197
On January 9, 2019 at 09:17, goldenzrule said...
It's not a $199 remote.  It will not function on its own.  At minimum, it is a $700 remote.  If you are simply adding it to a system that already is getting a processor, then maybe you can consider it a $199.

You need to sell a network too, and if it's not Pakedge you probably aren't getting support. How much is that?
"try to become not a man of success, but try rather to become a man of value."
Post 20 made on Wednesday January 9, 2019 at 13:54
Brett Bjorkquist
Long Time Member
Joined:
Posts:
March 2018
19
Good morning everyone, and thanks to HighFigh for emailing me to alert me to the thread.

In case you haven't seen my other thread posts, I head up Installer Services at Logitech Harmony, so I'm happy to answer all of these comments. I was brought into Harmony about 2 years ago to specifically build out the installer channel. As many like HighFigh, FunHouse, and 2nd Rick have mentioned, we've built some great support tools for dealers that I'm happy to share.

James_AA: The issue you mentioned would not affect the installation you are discussing. If you are having an issue getting the remotes working, I'm happy to have myself or my Harmony guru Pike give you a call. Just email me to let me know. [email protected]

Very specifically, the issue that came up a few weeks ago, revolved around a port we had open, that we used years ago. It could only be accessed locally if they were already on that person's network, but it was brought to our attention that it was accessible in that specific instance, and so we closed it to further protect our customers. The unintentional consequence is that there were people using an unsupported API through this port that lost access. As mentioned, they responded, and Harmony worked to get a better understanding of who this was affecting, and found a workaround to keep the security implementation for everyone, but allow these DIY groups to gain back the port since they are Harmony supporters even if we didn't fully understand their use case previously...

Unless you are using a control protocol that was specifically hacking into your Harmony Hub locally on your network (you would know this) it does not affect anyone else. This was less than 1% of our user base, but all customers are important to Harmony and I feel Logitech took the steps needed to provide great customer service, and began to turn around a solution within a few days.

All official IP, BT, IR controls were not affected. That means Sonos, Heos, Sony, Nest, EcoBee, Dish, Roku, FireTV, AppleTV, Lutron, Hue, etc. are all working fine. Again message me if you want some help with this account, which hopefully you are managing through the dealer portal, otherwise I can get you on board.

Also, just to clarify, the remote and hub are connected by RF not over BT. We use BT to connect the app to the hub when initially programming, and for BT devices like FireTV, PS3/4, Shield and others.

Trunk Slammer: Not sure that comment was really meant to be helpful. ; )

I couldn't tell you what the client's issue is from this post, but I can say that our Harmony remotes have less than a .5% RMA rate when professionally installed, so it likely doesn't need to be replaced or scrapped, especially not with the device list he mentioned, and if it was working previously. If it does, we happily support our dealers and their clients. Clients have issues across all control platforms and it is usually based on programming, not the hardware, as I'm sure you would agree.

I am rebuilding my system at the moment, it's 12 zones of Sonos, 40 Ra2Select lights, 8 Hue bulbs, Nest thermostat, three rooms of TV, and pretty much every streamer. I also have Alexa and Google integrated into the system, and can control all my lights, group sonos activities, add/remove and discretely control the volume in each room from my Harmony remote or app. I can also access any of my sources (other than my Xbox One S) without the need for a distribution switch. I have automation and am adding sensors to trigger, and love the various Pico keypads around the home. There are many larger installs than mine, but if the thought is that Harmony is just DIY, that is truly not the case. I'm always happy to discuss if you want to email me.

3pedalmini: I always tell people to sell the brands they want, but in most cases, dealers selling Harmony are actually returning high-net profit on their jobs because programming is far more efficient, and clients get rock solid solutions that don't often require additional support. Plus, if a client needs a new favorite channel or activity added, dealers can program and push the update from wherever they are without rolling a truck. Rather than a more complex control solution than they likely need, get them another speaker, bigger TV, or add some additional lighting. You shouldn't be making less or doing smaller jobs with Harmony, you should be making more and doing more work but letting the client spend their money on things they feel create additional value. That could be an ultra customized control system, but most clients just want a simple easy to use and reliable system, and would prefer the other items that they can hear, see, and feel.

I just chatted with an installer two days ago who pulled out another system, and replaced it with 8 Harmony remotes. System works great, and clients are much happier now because it's far more reliable than the control system that was there previously. Again, I don't think it was the product, it was the installer that works or in this case didn't work their magic; we just make it easier to work more magic.. ; )

Dunnersfella: I obviously agree that it doesn't have ethernet, but we have millions of hub users and there aren't too many issues connecting wirelessly. Of course like all these other connected products, it starts with a properly built Wi-Fi system. I do agree it's nice to have ethernet though, which is why we are adding it to a new Pro product coming out later this year. I'm testing it right now, and running it over PoE, so I even get rid of the wall wart. We're listening to the installers, and of course I have similar needs from my 18 years in the CE/CI industry.

I appreciate the support 2nd Rick. Rick is an industry vet, much like HighFigh, and many others supporting Harmony on this thread attesting that Harmony builds great products and supports our dealers. If it's been a few years, or you've just put Harmony in the DIY bin, email me at [email protected] and I'm happy to walk you through everything we offer now.

TechValley: I totally agree that IoT is taking over, and it is the best thing possible for this industry. Brands like Sonos have introduced more people to the idea of audio distribution, and Nest has made the $200 thermostat the norm. Dealers should take advantage of this, and offer bigger systems, knowing that the reliability of these products is super high, as they all have millions of devices out there they are supporting. There will always be the customer who wants to spend more or wants what others don't have, or needs a custom button with a picture of their dog on it. Sell them another system, but realize there is a much bigger opportunity when you start selling to the middle of the pyramid and not just the top. Most people want and are willing to pay for the help just like the 1%. Just because someone can program a Harmony or Sonos on their own doesn't mean they don't want help, or your expertise in showing them what else is possible. We have over 2.4 millions lights, and over 500k wireless audio devices connected to our hubs, so the people obviously want connected homes and need us to help get them there. You seem to get this TechValley, so ping me if you aren't using Harmony yet, and I'll walk you through how we work with the brands you mentioned.

AndrewinBoulder: I don't debate that harmony is sold on the internet, and that many times it is sold below MSRP. I will say that Harmony Pro is extremely clean, and is what the CI channel should be offering. New product I am working on will provide better distinction between lines, but as HighFigh mentioned, it is usually some dealer doing something shady who has a couple of remotes, and then the "price searching bots" grab it, and you see Amazon dropping price to match. THat's not really Amazon's fault, and we actually spend quite a bit of time and money buying up this product to try to get it off the sites, while pushing the dealers to take it down. We continue to try to do better, but in the meantime guys like JJ over at Digital Delight in Texas have sold more than 450 harmony remotes in just the past year with a total company size of five (three installers), so it seems like this isn't an issue for many dealers. Always happy to discuss.

Goldenzrule: Thanks, that was pretty accurate. The only thing I'd add is that this affected less than 1% of our customers using an unsupported 3rd party driver to control Harmony in their homes with another 3rd party controller. We want to support those users too, which is what we are trying to do now that we know. I think it's important in these threads to make sure everyone realizes this never affected anyone using Harmony software, or approved integrations, as I don't want end users or integrators to worry.

I think that covered everyone. As I mentioned feel free to reach out if you have any questions. We work super hard to support our dealer channel, and always have some great demo pricing and other things I can share, but won't post here openly. ; )

Oh yeah, can't remembered but someone mentioned local control. For anything IR, we control that over local, so when internet goes out, it still works. Many IP integrations like Nest require cloud based interaction so those are not local for anyone using an approved API so far as I know. So it is a mix of both local or cloud control depending on the device we are controlling, but IR devices like the OP talked about should all be local from the remote.

Opinions and comments are mine as an integration professional and not official company statements.

Have a great day,
Brett Bjorkquist
Logitech - CI/Pro Channel
[email protected]
Post 21 made on Wednesday January 9, 2019 at 13:58
Brett Bjorkquist
Long Time Member
Joined:
Posts:
March 2018
19
That didn't look as long in the small box I wrote it in... ; )

Hopefully I covered everything.

Dealers can email me or go to pro.myharmony.com to sign up.

The dealer support line is specifically for dealers, so I don't post it anywhere public, but it is clearly shown on the dealer portal, and in Harmony Pro packaging.
(We have great consumer support as well, and both are open 7-days-a-week.)
Brett Bjorkquist
Logitech - CI/Pro Channel
[email protected]
Post 22 made on Wednesday January 9, 2019 at 17:48
Trunk-Slammer -Supreme
Loyal Member
Joined:
Posts:
November 2003
7,454
On January 8, 2019 at 20:59, 2nd rick said...
Lots of Harmony hate on here from people who don't have experience with it.

Kelly, do you also hate on the 2019 Hyundai model lineup because your baby sister had a bad experience with her used Scoupe in 1992? :)

Nah. I like "HI UND DAY"...lol

Harmony dislike due to experience. I also cannot understand why someone wants to sell a product they don't really make any money on, but then again. a lot of guys jumped on the Sonos bandwagon.

Easy and low profit. What a great reason to sell something.
Post 23 made on Wednesday January 9, 2019 at 17:57
FunHouse Texas
Active Member
Joined:
Posts:
June 2013
595
Harmony dislike due to experience.

remember the Onkyo/Integra HDMI debacle about 10 years ago?
I AM responsible for typographical errors!
I have all the money I will ever need - unless i buy something..
Post 24 made on Wednesday January 9, 2019 at 18:02
goldenzrule
Loyal Member
Joined:
Posts:
July 2007
8,470
On January 9, 2019 at 17:48, Trunk-Slammer -Supreme said...
Nah. I like "HI UND DAY"...lol

Harmony dislike due to experience. I also cannot understand why someone wants to sell a product they don't really make any money on, but then again. a lot of guys jumped on the Sonos bandwagon.

Easy and low profit. What a great reason to sell something.

The industry is changing and the thinking has to as well. Sonos on its own, as a small system does the make as much money. Do a 12 zone system, with speakers, labor, maybe some other add-ons makes for a decent pay day with no service calls. You shouldn't be worried about making a killing on a remote as its not often you are selling just a remote. It would be part of a larger system. Like it or not, the high margin days are going away, and have on many items. Yes, I'd love to see more margin in every product I sell, but I don't think it's a valid reason to not sell stuff in today's market. More labor, less service calls, perhaps more add-ons, and sleep better at night when people are no longer calling at 9pm because their remote won't control an AppleTV on one of 13 TV's in their house.
Post 25 made on Wednesday January 9, 2019 at 18:41
Brett Bjorkquist
Long Time Member
Joined:
Posts:
March 2018
19
Agreed Goldenzrule. Gross margin is only one component of a net profitable business, and business owners should be looking at all the factors in their company's net profit, not just the one. Gross margin, labor margin, RMA, returns, truck rolls, marketing, time spent on proposals, time spent on training, and the extra troubleshooting time that everyone does are just some of the things to think about.

Manufacturers push gross margin because it's an easy thing for a manufacturer to talk about, especially when there is nothing else to differentiate their product. That's why so many people use Sonos. It's not that dealers don't want more margin (who turns away free money), it's because it's easy to sell, easy to program, rarely has issues, and they spend millions of dollars on advertising to get people interested, which is worth more than the extra 10pts you might want. Everyone gets to choose what they value in their business, but if you don't focus on the changing industry, it's easy to get bypassed by those that do. I started in the time of Prontos, Mitsubishi Diamond RP, and $5k 480P Fujitsu plasmas. Guess how many of those are still being offered? Yet many dealers are making more money now because they've shifted their business model to adapt and focus on servicing their clients to build a healthy business. They've also learned to build a more robust marketing engine, rather than just relying on referrals and extra margin from the good times to cover the lean times.

Here's a link to an article on JJ Canon over at Digital Delight. He's installed over 450 Harmony remotes in just the past year, and most have Eero, Sonos, Lutron, Rachio, Roku and many other products, plus solid labor, and he has far fewer headaches; all resulting in being up 50% in net profit.

[Link: cepro.com]

I can respect anyone's choice in manufacturer as there are plenty of options and it's ultimately their business. If the main objection though is a few dollars margin or experiences from years ago, I'd recommend taking another look. Just about everyone that does, confirms it is a great system and that the time savings and lower price point provides a solid value to their client and their bottom line.

My $.02, well okay maybe $.05 cents.
Brett Bjorkquist
Logitech - CI/Pro Channel
[email protected]
Post 26 made on Thursday January 10, 2019 at 08:38
therockhr
Long Time Member
Joined:
Posts:
February 2015
27
On January 9, 2019 at 13:58, Brett Bjorkquist said...
That didn't look as long in the small box I wrote it in... ; )

Hopefully I covered everything.

Dealers can email me or go to pro.myharmony.com to sign up.

The dealer support line is specifically for dealers, so I don't post it anywhere public, but it is clearly shown on the dealer portal, and in Harmony Pro packaging.
(We have great consumer support as well, and both are open 7-days-a-week.)

Any chance Harmony will get IP control of Denon receivers and Russound multi-zone receivers (like the MCA-C5 and MCA-88)? What about control of Global Cache devices and serial drivers?
Post 27 made on Thursday January 10, 2019 at 16:36
Brett Bjorkquist
Long Time Member
Joined:
Posts:
March 2018
19
Hey Therockhr,

I push heavily for IP on those lines, especially the D&M and Russound product. There is a bit of a chicken/egg with this in that consumers aren't using it as much as dealers, so I need the dealer growth to be able to request more resources for more IP. (My current priority has been on the new dealer portal, and new product for the channel, but we've been working on new IP as well, it just becomes prioritization like anything else).

Out of curiosity, I would think that in the case of a Russound or most AVRs, that the hub would typically be located in the same area as the equipment. Are you finding that the IR/RS232 on the Russound isn't as accurate as the IP? I'm curious if it opens up DSP or any new features we can't access from an IR code? I was always a bigger Niles guy, and in the past few years have moved over to Sonos to pull the source and amp together. The MCA-88 is in our system as an example, and for the most part, if a device uses discrete codes which this does, there shouldn't be any issues. Same with any of the AVRs. I am testing an Onkyo at the moment with their new Sonos compatibility, but have had Denon product in my home for the past 15+ years, plus selling Sony ES, Pioneer, Integra, etc. As a rule if there is a 3.5male to male input I use that, and can't remember the last time I missed a command. With that said, I agree things are going to IP, and prefer to use it where I can, I just think that with discrete codes, and Harmony power settings, we are able to still control most of what the dealer/client needs, but always appreciate hearing what's important to the channel.

If you shoot me an email, I can get you added to our webinar and dealer training, where we are always talking about these kinds of things. Plus we are working on a dealer forum so we can help, and other Harmony experts can ask and answer as well.
Brett Bjorkquist
Logitech - CI/Pro Channel
[email protected]
Page 2 of 2


Jump to


Protected Feature Before you can reply to a message...
You must first register for a Remote Central user account - it's fast and free! Or, if you already have an account, please login now.

Please read the following: Unsolicited commercial advertisements are absolutely not permitted on this forum. Other private buy & sell messages should be posted to our Marketplace. For information on how to advertise your service or product click here. Remote Central reserves the right to remove or modify any post that is deemed inappropriate.

Hosting Services by ipHouse