You're saying Justin and Ariat last forever? Surely you mean Redwing. Ive own just about every manufacturer. Ariat's are most comfortable, out of box. Justin is cheap. NEITHER last any length of time. Redwings are VERY long lasting. However, prepare for the break in period as Redwing (talking cowboy style, ropers) are atrocious and painful the first few weeks, but actually worth it as once broke in, fit like a glove and can last for years. ALL others require a new purchase once a year, period. I only rear ropers, always have. Only. Redwing IS the best but boy you pay for it the first few weeks.

Its been a long time since I bought work boots. I have never heard of many of the brands mentioned. Red Wing, Danner, Bogs, etc.

I tend to wear more comfortable shoes or sneakers like vans at final or work on a completed house. Don the work boots when going through gut remodel, etc.

The Bogs look interesting for landscape given the material and construction of the boots. Assuming they will hold up to mud & muck that killed my last boots. Then can look at a different brand like Red Wing, etc to wear during construction phase.

I like Wolverines, wear like iron and are comfortable.