Just an update here, for those who wondered what I eventually did...

Version 3 of my antenna was an abject failure, next is version 4.

Wire for ties was 18 guage aluminum, way too thin, could barely bring anything in.  Will try 14 guage copper for the next one.  Wires at 9" were too long, while bottom end stations 9 to 25 came in excellent, 64-66 became hit and miss.  Will try 8 1/4  for the next one.  The idea is to have the antenna peak at around 40, but still strong enough for both 9 at the bottom at 66 at the top. 

Used aluminum plates as a reflector, this didn't work, I have some aluminum window screening from trying to protect indoor plants from the cats,  the piece is quite large, so will use either wood or wire to make a frame to fit the back of the entenna, with the screening attached.  This should make the antenna work better and look better as well. 

If this does not work, it will need to be moved outside.  Anyone know how to waterproof the connections?