DirecTV is as good as it gets, with our without TIVO.

Comcast via motorola boxes is the cable option where im from and they suck. The interface is rediculous.

I upgraded a client to an Comcast moto HD DVR a couple years ago and it wouldnt play nice with a lexicon so he wasnt able to get analog audio. Nice huh?

[Link: dslreports.com] My user name there is/was StallIN.