I recently bought the external HP DVD Writer that is as simple as it gets. It's firewire\USB2 compatible and has S Video & Composite inputs right on the back. I put an old VCR right next to it (actually under my printer) and fired up the software that came with the DVD recorder. Pop in a video tape and the software prompts you right through the process. You can copy 1 or more tapes in a row-- stop and go as you wish. You can burn right to the DVD or choose to save the video on the hard drive, edit it and burn later.

I didn't even look at the manual yet, but there are options for quality ( 1or 2 hours\dvd) and I've burned some at both settings with very little difference noticeable on my70"Sony LCD!

May not be the best, but certainly simple-- and as an external, you can move it around! I only wish it had the new "LightScribe" labeling feature HP is touting because that looks nice, although the media is probably way overpriced!