I have had both but have Uverse now. The picture quality is fairly compressed and overall not that great. Their internet services are fairly good dependent on location. The DVR portion is ok and the ability to pick up watching programs in different rooms is nice. I feel the picture from Comcast is a bit less compressed and the internet services I got from Comcast was strong. So in summation if I could get Comcast in my area I would have their service. I also heard that later this year comcast is gonna add the ability to watch programs across different DVR's in the home.